Skip to main content
DiagXCar
Pumpkin pieBanana cream pie VS
Foods comparedPumpkin pie is lighter

Pumpkin pie vs Banana cream pie

Counter, fridge and freezer times side by side, with USDA nutrition per 100 g.

Pumpkin pie · fridge

3–4 days

Banana cream pie · fridge

3–4 days

Pumpkin pie · freezer

1–2 months

Banana cream pie · freezer

Not recommended

Quick answer

Both keep about the same time: 3–4 days in the fridge. Per 100 g, pumpkin pie has fewer calories (243 vs 269 kcal). Banana cream pie has more protein per 100 g and more fat.

Pumpkin pie vs Banana cream pie: Storage Side by Side

Pumpkin pieBanana cream pie
CounterRefrigerateafter openingRefrigerateafter opening
Fridge3–4 days40°F (4°C) or colder3–4 days40°F (4°C) or colder
Fridge, opened3–4 days3–4 days
Freezer1–2 monthsNot recommended
Thawed, in fridge——
Left outFine while sealedFine while sealed
Freezes well?Yes, for a short stretchNot recommended

Which Lasts Longer, Pumpkin pie or Banana cream pie?

In the fridge

Both keep about the same time: 3–4 days in the fridge.

In the freezer

Pumpkin pie: 1–2 months. Banana cream pie: not recommended. Freezer times are for quality; food held at 0°F (-18°C) stays safe.

On the counter

Neither needs the fridge while sealed.

Why the difference?

Pumpkin pie holds more water (50.4 g per 100 g against 47.9 g). Moisture is what bacteria and mold need, so wetter foods usually spoil sooner.

Can You Freeze Pumpkin pie and Banana cream pie?

Pumpkin pie

Yes, for a short stretch. Held at 0°F / -18°C, it keeps its best quality for roughly 1–2 months. Food that stays frozen remains safe indefinitely; only the quality slips over time.

Leftovers: check it.

Banana cream pie

Not recommended. FoodKeeper advises against freezing banana cream pie: the texture falls apart, or the thawed result can't be trusted to be safe.

Leftovers: check it.

Pumpkin pie vs Banana cream pie: Nutrition per 100 g

Per 100 gPumpkin pieBanana cream pieDifference
Calories243 kcal269 kcal−26 kcal
Protein3.9 g4.4 g−0.5 g
Fat9.8 g13.6 g−3.8 g
Saturated fat2 g3.8 g−1.8 g
Carbohydrates34.8 g32.9 g+1.9 g
Sugars18.9 g12.1 g+6.8 g
Fiber1.8 g0.7 g+1.1 g
Sodium239 mg240 mg−1 mg
Water50.4 g47.9 g+2.5 g
Cholesterol26 mg51 mg−25 mg

Pumpkin pie: where the calories come from

Carbs 57% · Protein 6% · Fat 36%

Banana cream pie: where the calories come from

Carbs 48% · Protein 6% · Fat 45%

Typical servingWeightCalories
Pumpkin pie · 1 oz28.4 g69 kcal
Banana cream pie · 1 oz28.4 g76 kcal

Source: USDA FoodData Central (SR Legacy). Banana cream pie is saltier per 100 g.

How to Tell If Pumpkin pie or Banana cream pie Has Gone Bad

Both spoil the same way, so watch for the same signs:

  • Odor: A sour, musty or boozy smell.
  • Texture: Dry and hard just means stale, which is still safe; damp or tacky is a different story.
  • Color: Odd-colored spots on the crumb or the crust.
  • Mold: If you can see mold anywhere, throw out the entire item — its roots reach further than the eye can see.
Full guide Pumpkin pie→Full guide Banana cream pie→

Pumpkin pie vs Banana cream pie: Frequently Asked Questions

Which lasts longer, pumpkin pie or banana cream pie?

Both keep about the same time: 3–4 days in the fridge.

Which has fewer calories, pumpkin pie or banana cream pie?

Per 100 g, pumpkin pie has fewer calories (243 vs 269 kcal).

Which has more protein?

Banana cream pie: 4.4 g per 100 g, against 3.9 g for pumpkin pie.

Can you freeze pumpkin pie and banana cream pie?

Pumpkin pie: yes, for a short stretch (1–2 months). Banana cream pie: not recommended.

Can you store pumpkin pie and banana cream pie together?

Yes, they need the same conditions: a cool, dry place, sealed after opening. Keep each in its own container so one doesn't shorten the other's life.

Are pumpkin pie and banana cream pie safe after a night on the counter?

Both are shelf-stable while sealed; once opened, follow each one's own times.

More Comparisons

All comparisons →

Storage data from USDA FoodKeeper; nutrition from USDA FoodData Central.

· How we check